Poison Pen Letters: Circleville and the Watcher

In Sight explores mysteries, true crime, and forgotten history. In this episode, Ali and Charlie explore two cases of Poison Pen letters.

Case #1: Who sent the letters that tormented the residents of Circleville, Ohio? Was Mary Gillispie targeted more so than the others? Was the fatal car crash that claimed her husband’s life an accident as the authorities ruled? Who left a booby trapped box in her path?

Case #2: Is there really a “Watcher” keeping guard of a house in Westfield, New Jersey? Are the letters that keep the new owners away from the house a hoax? Part of a larger scheme? Or is someone really waiting on “young blood” to move in?

Facebook/insightpod Twitter @insightfulpod Instagram @insightpod insightfulpod@gmail.com insightpod.com Cover art by Ali Music by Scott Buckley